Others from denomination react to Episcopal church split

Tools

By Arielle Clay aclay@nbcaugusta.com

AUGUSTA, Ga. - NBC Augusta 26 News told you earlier this week about a priest and dozens of members from a North Augusta church splitting from the congregation.

The group said they left St. John's Episcopal Church because they were dissatisfied with some of the national church's choices.

Others in the denomination spoke out about the split Wednesday.

Trish Darlington was born into the Episcopal church.

“I'm what they call a cradle Episcopalian. All my life. I was raised in the church,” Darlington said.

In her lifetime as an Episcopalian, she's had doubts about different changes in the church, from women priests to altered prayer books.

“When we started having women priests I was not a big supporter of that,” Darlington said. “I didn't like the new prayer book in 1979. I thought they had gone too far.”

But with time she changed her mind. Now she says she loves the prayer book and her current pastor is Sister Ellen Francis, a woman.

“There have been enough things in my life that I thought was set in stone and had to be a certain way and found out, boy, was I wrong,” Darlington said.

So when another change in the church came along, Darlington said she was much more willing to accept. This time the change garnered national attention, in 2003, when a gay man was consecrated as a Bishop.

“I was very pleased when Bishop Gene Robertson was consecrated Bishop,” Darlington said.

But all Episcopalians, like the former priest of St. John's Episcopal Church in North Augusta, S.C., were not as happy.

Father Robert Hartley stepped down as vicar of the church last Sunday and many of his congregants followed. To them allowing a gay bishop was wrong but it was not their main concern.

Church members said it only highlighted what they say is a much bigger problem: the Episcopal church interpreting scripture to make it easier to accept.

“Based on the agenda into the Episcopal church, there is a need for us to redefine what Christianity is about we really can't redefine what God has given us,” Hartley said.

Sister Francis and Darlington say the Bible should be used as a guide. Not every passage should be taken literally. Instead, scripture should be interpreted based on many things including cultural changes and reason.

“Advances in sciences and social science will be a part of how we read scripture,” Francis said.

“I'm not a Bible literalist. I don't read the Bible and say I'm going to take it exactly like it says when it talks about cutting off people's hands and not eating shellfish,” Darlington said.

Despite their differences in beliefs, Darlington said when she heard about Hartley and most of the congregation leaving St. John's she was saddened.

“It's just like losing a member of our family,” Darlington said.

The Bishop of the Diocese of which St. John's falls under is speaking out. He said he is completely surprised by the split. He said although Father Hartley did tell him about his frustrations, he was not aware that Hartley was on the verge of leaving. He also said any division in the church weakens the church's mission.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of NBC Augusta 26 | news, weather, sports, community, entertainment, shopping for Augusta, Georgia. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Thursday, Jan 8 at 5:02 PM Jay Robins wrote ...

"(S)cripture should be interpreted based on many things including cultural changes...." This is absolute garbage, but it does seem to inform much of TEC's recent thought. Unfortunately, as our culture gets dumbed down, so does the worth of TEC's product(it's no longer religion). Regretably, for many of us, the old trappings, and beautiful gothic churches are not enough without the theological core. But then, to KILTYONE, we are merely "deadwood." However, I prefer this to being brain dead.

14587428
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jan 8 at 4:59 PM Bruce Garner wrote ...

If those who accuse the Episcopal Church of interpretting Scripture to accommodate sin actually followed every one of the rules in the Hebrew Scriptures and the New Testament, they might have a valid argument. They don't and never have. They search for a "pure" church. They will never find that. Even Jesus noted that he hadn't come to save the righteous. Jesus was about as inclusive as one could get. Who are we not to follow the example of the One we claim to follow?

14587234
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jan 8 at 3:41 PM amber wrote ...

who r u to forgive sin? John 14:15 " if you love Me, Keep my commandments."

14582244
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jan 8 at 12:04 AM robroy wrote ...

"Good riddance. We don't want those who actually accept and uphold scripture. Come as you are and we will bless it no matter what. We are building an inclusive church!" Funny how the "inclusive" Episcopal denomination is the fastest declining in the country. "All are made in the image of God, so all are acceptable." What a stupid argument. The same argument could justify adultery, rape, murder, or those who torture gerbils. Come to the Episcopal church. We took a vote and did away with sin!

14548693
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jan 7 at 11:23 PM kilty wrote ...

It is good that the church is going through this cleansing. Once the deadwood is gone things can get back to the real mission of the church. That is, they can grow in accepting individualism. This is not a church of cookie cutter people. Afterall all people are supposed to made in the likeness of God. Therefore, all are acceptable to Him. Kiltyone@dslextreme.com

14547218
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

WAGT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. Comments are posted on site immediately and without station moderation. If you feel a comment is inappropriate you may flag it for review. For guidelines on flagging comments see our Terms & Conditions. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

More Good Stuff

Advertisement

WAGT Weather

Click here for 7 Day Forecast
Icon
Current Temp 42.0 °F
Fair
More Weather

WAGT Weather

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

NBC Augusta 26 RSS FeedsNBC Augusta 26 Twitter Feed NBC Augusta 26 Facebook Page NBC Full Shows Online

Viewer Poll

What do you think about Tiger's return to golf for the Masters Tournament?

  • Too soon, he should focus on his family
  • He's apologized, it's time for him to return to the game