Woman who claims Clearwater fire chief assaulted her speaks out

Tools

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

By Arielle Clay aclay@nbcaugusta.com

AIKEN, S.C. - A woman who claims she was assaulted by the Clearwater fire chief is telling her story.

The incident happened in 2007. But it was not until Thursday Chief Michael Toole was served that warrant and turned himself in.

While looking for a warrant for a person with a similar name, deputies came across Toole's and served him. The Aiken County Sheriff's Office says the mistake was caused by a backlog.

The alleged victim says it was too long to wait.

“I was like, oh my gosh. I really thought they had arrested him and forgotten to call me,” the alleged victim who wishes to not have her face or name shown said.

She is referring to Clearwater Fire Chief Michael Toole. She says in August 2007, when she was 17 Toole assaulted her while they were both doing work at a home in Aiken County.

“He drove up to the driveway and just started talking and said you have something on your shirt and brushed me off right here and asked if he could come in the house,” she said.

Based on the incident report, Toole says he did speak to the woman, but didn't touch her breast. She says Toole insisted that he come in but she didn't let him. She called the police to file this incident report. Then a warrant for battery and assault was put out for Toole's arrest. But he was never served.

“That was it. I never heard anything until I got the phone call yesterday,” she said.

Captain Troy Elwell of the Aiken County Sheriff's Office says they tried to serve Toole once. When they were unable to reach him, the warrant was logged in their records and forgotten until Thursday afternoon.

“We have a severe back log and just don't have the manpower to serve all the warrants we have,” Elwell said.

As to questions of possible favoritism towards Toole, Elwell says that is not the case.

“As soon as the administration found out that we had a warrant for this individual we contacted him within minutes,” Elwell said.

Toole turned himself in Thursday and has since been released on bond. Now his alleged victim says she is just glad this is all nearing an end.

“It could have happened to other people so I wish it hadn't taken so long,” the alleged victim said.

Next up, Toole will head to court for this case. As for that backlog Elwell says they get about 3,000 warrants a year and are struggling to serve them all.

View comments

The following comments do not necessarily represent the views of NBC Augusta 26 | news, weather, sports, community, entertainment, shopping for Augusta, Georgia. Users have agreed to these terms and in doing so accept full responsibility for their comments. Moderation is limited.

Friday, Jun 5 at 12:15 PM Disloyal Volunteer wrote ...

What kind of assistant fire chief would arrest his own fire chief? Sheriff Mike Hunt doesn't have any loyality or honesty toward anyone he works with or for. He's one dirty SOB.

23281294
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 22 at 9:36 PM Assistant Solicitor wrote ...

How is asssistant solcitor brenda brisbin able to sleep at night knowing that this animal is free and walking the streets of aiken county?

22076087
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 8:40 PM mike hunt is my idol wrote ...

to all the crybabies..mike hunt is this counties shining light..remember the train wreck,tornadoes etc.when you need help the first people there and the last people to leave are the ACSO!so stop whining!sheriff hunt will be sheriff long after mike toole is convicted and forgotten about.

21778654
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, May 16 at 8:55 PM lil one wrote ...

I think that the sheriff department works hard and they do there best to serve and protect the community. dont let this incident create a bad rep for the deputies. The girl did what she thought was right.

21608474
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, May 16 at 11:28 AM SLED Investigation wrote ...

If you have information about misconduct in office, such as improper destruction of warrants, suppressing warrants, using an outstanding warrants to intimidate someone, etc., involving Sheriff Mike Hunt please call SLED Director Reggie Lloyd or Deputy SLED Director Neal Dolan at (803) 896-4698.

21595282
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, May 16 at 9:14 AM QUESTON wrote ...

IF SOMEONE IS HIRED FOR A CHEIF POSISTION OF A FIRE DEPT. DON'T THEY DO A BACKGROUND CK, AND IF SO SOMEONE ON THE HIRING TEAM AT N. AUGUSTA OVERLOOKED THE WARRENT???? AND YES I DO BELIEVE CERTAIN PEOPLE CLOSE TO THE SHEIFF GET SPECIAL TREATMENT, HAS ANYONE EVER FIXED A "TICKET" FOR YOU. WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE....BURY A WARRENT.

21591744
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 15 at 5:30 PM Polygraph Test wrote ...

Why doesn't the media ask Sheriff Mike Hunt to take a polygraph test about this and see if he knew about the warrant, or did he tell someone else about the warrant prior to its service? We are confident that Tommy Platt can get to the truth.

21573839
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 15 at 4:53 PM jackson wrote ...

This girl is a good kid-not a liar.She was terrified of this jerk.And she didn't know who he was, and he was not the chief at that point.I wonder if anyone else is brave enough to come forward now that everyone is blasting her for telling the truth.Hope you people don't have kids!

21572049
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 15 at 3:16 PM Anonymous wrote ...

How is that the Aiken County has over 3,000 warrants backlogged and yet this warrant all of a sudden pops up after 2 years? Seems to be coincidence that it just popped up when they were looking for someone else. Why is that long term friends such as Toole and Hunt are no longer friends and the sheriff dumps his longtime friend who did the right thing by turning himself in? Looks like Hunt is trying boost his record and cover his but by putting the spotlight on another delicate situation.

21566772
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 15 at 6:50 AM Troy is Struggling wrote ...

Troy is obviously lying about this incident. Tommy Platt, Aiken Sheriff Office polygraph operator, should put him on the polygraph, ask him some questions about this case, and then share the results with the media. If he fails, and he will, he should be terminated immediately from the sheriff's office.

21538792
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 15 at 6:41 AM Similiar Allegations wrote ...

Wonder if she, or some other female, made the same or similiar unfounded allegations againt Sheriff Mike Hunt, if he would have been arrested?

21538587
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, May 14 at 6:01 PM Others Innocent in Aiken wrote ...

Joel Bedenbaugh, Stephanie Kirkland, Stephen Eubanks, Jeff Nations are all innocent in Aiken County too. Joel the outstanding art teacher for many years lost his job and teaching certificate. Stephanie, the 20 year old cheerleading instructor was accused of criminal sexual conduct with a female minor (three counts of rape, go figure), Stephen Eubanks denied bond then put on house arrest at his own expense still waiting for trial, and Jeff Nation, former deputy fired still waiting for trial.

21520192
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, May 14 at 5:50 PM NICK32 wrote ...

AND THANK GOODNESS WE ALL DONT GET FIRED EVERYTIME SOMEONE ACCUSES US OF SOMETHING.AS FAR AS THE CLEARWATER COMMISIONERS,THEY ARE COMPLETELY SPINELESS,AND THERE ARE TWO OF THEM THAT ARE JUST COMPLETELY SPINELESS,ESPECIALLY THE CHAIRMAN.I JUST HOPE WHEN THIS ALL PLAYS OUT,AND MR. TOOLE IS EXXONERATED,THAT ALL OF YOU WHO HAVE HELPED TO CONDEMN HIM ,SPEAK UP AS EAGERLY WITH AN APOLOGY.

21519632
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, May 14 at 5:47 PM Nick34 wrote ...

I THOUGHT THAT THE FIRE DEPARTMENT IN CLEARWATER WAS A "VOLUNTEER"FIRE DEPARTMENT.I ALSO THOUGHT THAT WHEN PEOPLE VOLUNTEER ,THE COMMUNITY SHOULD BE THANKFUL,ABOUT EVERY 12 TO 18 MONTHS,CLEARWATER HAS A NEW CHEIF AND NEW OFFICERS.HOW CAN THE OTHER "VOLUNTEER" FIRE DEPARTMENTS KEEP THE SAME CHEIF FOR YEARS,AND LITTLE OLE CLEARWATER VILLAGE CANNOT KEEP A CHEIF.I ALSO BELIEVE THAT ALL THAT HAS HAPPENED SO FAR IS AN ACCUSATION,HE STILL HAS TO BE PROVEN GUILTY,UNTIL THEN MIKE TOOLE IS INNOCENT.

21519492
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, May 14 at 3:45 PM Joel wrote ...

That's nothing Joel Bedenbaugh was picked up by Aiken County while living in Camden and denied bond for essentially the same allegation until Circuit Court Judge Early set bond a few months later. Judge Sheridan Lynn, who is not qualified to be a magistrate without a two degree, is in their pockets too.

21511397
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, May 14 at 3:32 PM Sheriff Can't Talk Sick Again wrote ...

Why has Sheriff Mike Hunt even refused to talk to the Aiken Standard about this incident? Jim Bouknight was charged $1087.50 for this charge and required to spend the night in the detention center. What was Mike Toole's bond amount and did he spend the night in the detention center?

21510462
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 13 at 10:18 PM James wrote ...

If you want to claim your innocence on national television, and prove to everyone here in Augusta that you did nothing wrong, then I urge you to go on the steve wilkos show. They are looking for people with these types of stories. Go to www.stevewilkos.com and click "Ask steve for help." Check out the videos to see what he's about.

21402074
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 13 at 9:02 AM Jeff wrote ...

If this were Jeff Nation the sheriff would have had him arrested over 18 months ago. Where is the Aiken Victim Advocacy Center on this story? What's their opinion of what just happened and how this victim has just been ignored for so long by the sheriff's office?

21353457
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 12 at 8:50 AM Lewd Act wrote ...

Why wasn't he charged with Lewd Act on a Minor. They should have called Chuck Cain in to investigate this sexual abuse crime. He would have made sure that he was charged appropriately.

21292719
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 11 at 6:01 PM James wrote ...

I agree the Sheriff is also a member of this dept. The sheriff should just stick to being the sheriff and leave the firefighting alone. We don't pay him for that anylonger. If he still wants to fight fires leave office! Remember he also dispatches for the Fire Dept in Aiken and the Fire Chief are having issues with him. however we are stuck with him for 3 more years. They who? Who will run?

21272034
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 11 at 4:27 PM Other Victims wrote ...

I wonder how many other victims are out there who Mike Toole has sexually assaulted. He is a preditor who knows how to put out as well as start a fire.

21266849
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 11 at 6:43 AM Joel wrote ...

The girls who accused Joel Bedenbaugh and Stephanie Kirkland of sexual abuse are also liars. But the person who said Mike Hunt was using county sheriff department vehicles to respond to fires is telling the truth. This is a criminal offense of misuse of government property and has not been authorized by the Aiken County Council. What do you think SLED?

21239319
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 10 at 9:45 PM Anonymous wrote ...

my chief would never do anything like that that woman is a lier

21232997
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 10 at 2:46 PM Former Deputy wrote ...

Mike Hunt didn't have any trouble finding Jeff Nation when he wanted to arrest him, but for some reason the elusive fire chief was too slick for him to find. Something else triggered the service of this warrant. Once again the sheriff's office is lying to the public in Aiken County.

21223757
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 10 at 12:41 PM News Release wrote ...

Why isn't this a news release on Sheriff Mike Hunt's website? What a double standard!

21220562
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 10 at 12:25 PM ABHAN wrote ...

Other people in Aiken are arrested for assault and battery high and aggravated (ABHAN) with similiar allegations. The aggravating circumstances being a difference in age and sex. How is it that Mike Hunt's buddies always get special treatment. All it takes is an allegation for a charge of this nature. Just ask good old boy Judge Sheridan Lynn at the Aiken County Detention Center.

21220189
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 10 at 11:02 AM Misconduct in Office wrote ...

Once again, Sheriff Mike Hunt has obstructed justice and attempted to avoid arrest of one of his friends like he did with the Darren Taylor CDV incident in Graniteville.

21217944
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 8 at 11:19 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Who cares if he is the assistant chief or a volunteer for Red Cross or a little league baseball coach. What does this have to do with a young lady making accusations against the current chief. I guess you also think the CIA had President Kennedy assassinated.

21174019
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 8 at 11:03 PM Anonymous wrote ...

The sheriff of Aiken County is the assistant Chief At Cleawater Fire Dept. What Wrong With This Picture !!!!!! You Need To Look More !!!!!!!

21173314
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

WAGT and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. Comments are posted on site immediately and without station moderation. If you feel a comment is inappropriate you may flag it for review. For guidelines on flagging comments see our Terms & Conditions. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

I have read and agree to the terms

Hide comments

More Good Stuff

Advertisement

WAGT Weather

Click here for 7 Day Forecast
Icon
Current Temp 61.0 °F
A Few Clouds
More Weather

WAGT Weather

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

NBC Augusta 26 RSS FeedsNBC Augusta 26 Twitter Feed NBC Augusta 26 Facebook Page NBC Full Shows Online

Viewer Poll

What do you think about Tiger's return to golf for the Masters Tournament?

  • Too soon, he should focus on his family
  • He's apologized, it's time for him to return to the game